The Kline Conflict -- A Row over Rowland | Speaker Law
phone icon email icon
(517) 482-8933

Speaker Law
Blog

The Kline Conflict -- A Row over Rowland

Posted on Monday, May 14, 2018

In Kline v Dep't of Tranportation, the Court of Appeals "begrudgingly" followed McCahan v Brennan, holding that the defendant was entitled to summary disposition where the plaintiff failed to comply with the notice provision contained in MCL 600.6431. In its opinion, the Court invoked conflict procedures in MCR 7.215(J)(2), indicating that it was following McCahan only because it had to, but that McCahan was wrongly decided.

 

In McCahan, the Court of Appeals relied on the Michigan Supreme Court's ruling in Rowland v Washtenaw Co Rd Comm, where the Court held that the notice provision of MCL 600.1404 did not contain a prejudice requirement and that the judiciary cannot read such a requirement into the statute. The panel in McCahan held that the Supreme Court's reasoning in Rowland was not limited to the MCL 600.1404 and should also be applied to MCL 600.6431(3) (The Court of Claims Act).

 

The majority (Judge Hoekstra dissented) in Kline opined that "McCahan was wrongly decided and that Rowland does not dictate the outcome in this case because it involves a different statutory provision. But for the mandate in MCL 7.215(J)(1), we wouldn not follw McCahan. Rather, we would affirm the trial court's order denying summary disposition." Stay tuned for updates on how this row over Rowland is resolved.

Do you have an appeal?
Let's find out!

Recent
Posts

Educational Neglect: Trial Court Correctly Assumed Jurisdiction Over Children
Oct 13, 2020
The Kalamazoo Circuit Court properly assumed jurisdiction over the ...
Trial Court Wrongly Imputed Overtime Income When Modifying Child Support
Oct 7, 2020
In this child-support modification case, the trial court erroneousl...
Trial Court Interfered With Parent’s Right To Question Guardian Ad Litem About Report
Sep 30, 2020
In this parenting-time dispute, the trial court improperly 1) treat...
Trial Court Must Re-Examine Request To Change Child’s School
Sep 23, 2020
A mother’s request to change the school of the parties’ minor child...

Tags

 

Subscribe to our blog

* indicates required