In this case involving an order for involuntary mental-health treatment, the Michigan Court of Appeals improperly dismissed as moot the respondent’s appeal of an expired order for treatment, the Michigan Supreme Court has ruled.
The Lenawee County Probate Court had found the respondent in In re TEB required mental-health treatment and, pursuant to the Michigan Mental Health Code, entered an order for treatment in July 2024. The respondent appealed that order. In a separate appeal, the respondent also challenged an order for treatment entered in January 2025, after the first order had expired.
The Court of Appeals dismissed the respondent’s appeal (Docket No. 372913). “Because the present appeal involves an expired order, and respondent has failed to point this Court to any practical legal consequences that will follow from this expired order, we dismiss the present appeal as moot,” the appeals court said.
In a two-page order, the Michigan Supreme Court reversed and remanded the case “for plenary consideration” (Docket No. 168741). “[T]he mootness exception applies to the involuntary mental health treatment order at issue in this case,” the high court wrote. “The Court of Appeals erred in concluding otherwise.”
Background & COA Opinion
In June 2024, the respondent was hospitalized after his psychiatrist recommended that he be evaluated. The petitioner then filed a petition seeking a combination of hospitalization and assisted outpatient treatment for the respondent. After a hearing, the Lenawee County Probate Court ordered the respondent be hospitalized. This July 2024 order expired in January 2025.
The respondent did not comply with the July 2024 order, resulting in the entry of an order after notice of the respondent’s noncompliance. The respondent’s mother subsequently filed a petition for involuntary mental-health treatment in January 2025, which the probate court granted that same month.
The respondent appealed the July 2024 order, arguing it was erroneously entered. The petitioner responded by asserting the appeal was moot.
“Respondent’s claim is, indeed, moot,” the Court of Appeals held in its May 2025 opinion. “The July 2024 order has expired by its own terms, the probate court entered a subsequent involuntary-treatment order in January 2025, and respondent has appealed that order. … Thus, this Court cannot order any relief in the present appeal that would have a practical effect on respondent’s involuntary treatment.”
Regarding the issue of collateral legal consequences, “in reply to petitioner’s argument on mootness, the sole consequence to which respondent specifically points this Court is his inability to possess a firearm lawfully,” the Court of Appeals said. “In the mine-run of similar cases, this consequence might well be sufficient to overcome mootness, … but here, (a) respondent has had multiple prior involuntary treatments/hospitalizations, (b) there is no record of those orders being appealed or otherwise challenged, and (c) the time for doing so has since lapsed. Thus, even if respondent were successful in the present appeal, he would still not be able to possess a firearm lawfully.”
The respondent further noted that, in addition to the firearm restrictions, “there are other potential downsides to having even an expired mental health order on one’s record which could potentially impact employment and other opportunities,” the Court of Appeals observed. However, the respondent “has not … relied on any legal authority or further developed this assertion, and, accordingly, he has abandoned the argument. … Finally, the merits of respondent’s involuntary treatment will not, in a practical sense, evade appellate review, given respondent’s appeal of the probate court’s January 2025 order.”
Accordingly, the Court of Appeals dismissed the respondent’s appeal as moot. The appellate panel included Judge Michael J. Kelly, Judge Brock A. Swartzle and Judge Matthew S. Ackerman.
MSC Reversal Order
At the outset of its order reversing the Court of Appeals, the Michigan Supreme Court explained that, under MCL 330.1472a(1)(c), involuntary mental-health treatment orders “are inherently limited in duration” and those that include combined hospitalization and outpatient treatment “may not exceed 180 days.”
As a result, “[t]he brief duration of these orders means that appellate review will frequently occur after the challenged order has expired by its own terms,” the high court pointed out, citing In re Tchakarova, 328 Mich App 172 (2019).
However, although an issue is moot, “it is nevertheless justiciable if the issue is one of public significance that is likely to recur, yet may evade judicial review,” the Michigan Supreme Court explained, referencing People v Richmond, 486 Mich 29 (2010).
“Like the 90-day order in In re Tchakarova, … the involuntary mental health order at issue in this case presents an issue of public significance and the limited duration of the 180-day order ‘all but guaranteed that no meaningful judicial review of the order could ever be conducted before the order expired,’” the justices observed.
“The Court of Appeals, nonetheless, dismissed respondent’s appeal of the July 2024 involuntary mental health treatment order as moot, concluding that ‘the merits of respondent’s involuntary treatment will not, in a practical sense, evade appellate review, given respondent’s appeal of the probate court’s January 2025 order,’” the high court noted. “Yet the Court of Appeals subsequently dismissed respondent’s appeal of the January 2025 order as moot.”
According to the Michigan Supreme Court, “This pattern of successive orders demonstrates precisely the capable of repetition, yet evading review circumstance that justifies an exception to mootness. The Court of Appeals holding would effectively immunize short-duration involuntary treatment orders from appellate scrutiny whenever a subsequent order is issued. Accordingly, the mootness exception applies to the involuntary mental health treatment order at issue in this case. The Court of Appeals erred in concluding otherwise.”