A houseguest who secretly placed recording devices in the host’s home did not have a reasonable expectation of privacy in the storage cards that the devices contained, the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled.
In United States v Mininger (Docket No. 25-10073), the defendant had secretly placed cameras in the home of his ex-wife, S.H., while visiting. The cameras were hidden in the bedroom and bathroom of S.H.’s 17-year-old daughter and one was aimed at the teen’s bed. When the cameras were eventually discovered, S.H. called police and gave written consent for a search of the devices’ storage cards (“SD cards”). Officers found footage on the SD cards that spanned several years, including video of S.H.’s daughter undressing when she was between 14 and 16 years old. Search warrants were ultimately obtained for the defendant’s residence, where police discovered four devices containing child pornography. A forensic examiner also accessed various encrypted files and found recordings of the defendant sexually abusing a child.
The defendant was charged with 16 counts of child pornography. He filed a motion to suppress the SD cards as evidence, arguing they were the product of a warrantless search. He also claimed the subsequent searches were tainted by the first search, and that the warrants were “overbroad.”
The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Alabama denied the defendant’s motion. According to the District Court, although the defendant did have a reasonable expectation of privacy in the SD cards, S.H. had the authority to consent to the search. The District Court sentenced the defendant to 600 months in prison.
The defendant appealed, asserting a Fourth Amendment challenge and arguing the District Court should have suppressed the evidence. The 11th Circuit affirmed the defendant’s convictions.
“No one could reasonably expect a right to privacy in voyeuristic recordings made under these circumstances,” the 11th Circuit said. “Accordingly, the warrantless search of the illicitly placed cameras and their SD cards was permissible.” Because the defendant “had no reasonable expectation of privacy in the SD cards he had placed, unsecured, in a shared room in his ex-wife’s house, [his] Fourth Amendment arguments fail.”
Judge Andrew L. Brasher wrote the opinion, joined by Judge Embry J. Kidd and Judge Charles R. Wilson.
‘Foolhardy’ Expectation
“This appeal raises two questions,” the 11th Circuit said at the outset of its opinion. “First, does a homeowner’s overnight guest have a reasonable expectation of privacy in the contents of a recording device when the guest places that device in a shared space without the homeowner’s knowledge or consent, fails to secure the contents, and uses it to invade the homeowner’s privacy? Second, must a warrant to search physical electronic de vices be limited in time or category as to the electronic files that may be reviewed? We answer both questions ‘no.’”
The 11th Circuit then addressed the defendant’s assertion that police conducted a warrantless search of the SD cards in violation of his Fourth Amendment rights and his reasonable expectation of privacy in the SD cards. Meanwhile, the government argued the District Court’s finding that the defendant had an expectation of privacy was erroneous.
Considering the “totality of the circumstances,” the defendant “had no expectation of privacy in the SD cards that society would be prepared to recognize as reasonable,” the 11th Circuit said. “Put another way, whatever his subjective expectation of privacy, there was no objectively reasonable expectation that the contents of the SD cards would remain private. After all, he placed the video cameras and their attendant SD cards in a shared area of S.H.’s home where they could easily be discovered, he failed to protect the contents with a password, and he used those cards to invade the privacy of S.H.’s family members. In such circumstances, [the defendant’s] expectation of privacy in the contents of the SD cards is ‘not only unreasonable, but foolhardy.’”
A person “ordinarily lacks a reasonable expectation of privacy in computer files that he makes readily accessible to third parties,” the 11th Circuit explained. “Here, S.H., her children, or any guest could examine the contents of these SD cards …. Because [he] placed the SD cards – and thus the cards’ contents – in a shared area, liable to be discovered and examined by a third party, and beyond his area of control, he cannot claim to have a reasonable expectation of privacy in their content.”
In addition, the cameras – “located as they were in the bedroom and bathroom of S.H.’s minor daughter – were self-evidently placed to illegally invade the privacy of S.H.’s children,” the 11th Circuit noted. “No one could reasonably expect a right to privacy in voyeuristic recordings made under these circumstances.”
To support his argument, the defendant pointed to Minnesota v Olson, 495 US 91 (1990), and the “legitimate expectation of privacy” that overnight guests have in a host’s home. “No doubt, an overnight guest retains a reasonable expectation of privacy notwithstanding that a host could, theoretically, look through his things while he is out,” the 11th Circuit wrote. “The Court in Olson stressed that this expectation of privacy is rooted in social norms and ‘the everyday expectations of privacy that we all share.’”
However, the reasoning in Olson did “not help” the defendant in the present case, the 11th Circuit observed. “An overnight houseguest has the highest legitimate expectation of privacy in his own quarters. … But, when guests leave unsecured belongings in shared areas, such as a bathroom, the expectation of privacy is much weaker. … And a guest’s reasonable expectation of privacy assumes a degree of reciprocity – the host and third parties will respect a guest’s right to privacy just as the guest and third parties will respect the host’s privacy. Consequently, no houseguest has a reasonable expectation of privacy in voyeuristic recordings made in his host’s home without his host’s knowledge or consent. When a guest so plainly exceeds the scope of societal custom and his host’s license, any expectation of privacy becomes unreasonable.”
Therefore, “we reject [the defendant’s] argument that the Fourth Amendment bars admission of the evidence gathered from the warrantless search of his SD cards,” the 11th Circuit held.
Cloud-Based Versus Electronic Storage
Next, the 11th Circuit turned to the defendant’s argument that the warrants issued for his residence, vehicles, devices and person were “overbroad.”
“Specifically, he complains that the warrants did not place ‘available, appropriate limits’ on law enforcement’s search of [his] devices,” the 11th Circuit noted. “He says that, because law enforcement had probable cause to search for pictures of specific people made during a specific time period, the Fourth Amendment requires them to have used forensics tools to limit their search to electronic files created of those specific people or during that particular time period.”
The 11th Circuit rejected the defendant’s argument.
“[O]ur case law does not require that a warrant impose a time limit or a similar restriction on the search of an electronic storage device,” the 11th Circuit explained, noting that it previously distinguished between electronic devices and cloud accounts in United States v Blake, 868 F3d 960 (11th Cir 2017).
In Blake, “we stressed that the ‘means of hiding evidence on a hard drive – obscure folders, misnamed files, encrypted data – are not currently possible in the context of a’ cloud-based account,” the 11th Circuit said. “’Hard drive searches require,’ as the facts of this case highlight, ‘time-consuming electronic forensic investigation with special equipment, and conducting that kind of search in the defendant’s home would be impractical, if not impossible.’ … ‘By contrast,’ with respect to cloud-based accounts, ‘the government need only send a request with the specific data sought and [the cloud service provider] will respond with precisely that data.’”
The present case “underscore[s] the difference between the search of a cloud-based account and the search of an electronic storage device,” the 11th Circuit emphasized. “The search warrants here were not directed at cloud accounts under the control of a third party; they were directed at electronic storage devices in [the defendant’s] physical possession. When these devices were in his possession, [he] had gone to great lengths to obfuscate the nature of his data, employing the VeraCrypt program to conceal the files. The search required that a forensic examiner break the encryption of [his] illicit files. This effort is a far cry from ‘send[ing] a request with the specific data sought’ to a cloud-service provider and receiving exactly that data. … It is not feasible for a warrant to limit the scope of a ‘hard drive search[],’ … in the same way a warrant might limit the search of a cloud account under the control of a third party.”
A warrant “must be as ‘specific as the circumstances and nature of activity under investigation permit[s],’” the 11th Circuit said. “Here, the relevant warrant was limited to seizing ‘records relating to Child Pornography and Sexual Exploitation.’ Accordingly, it was not overbroad.”